Car insurance premium increases no longer track individual claims. France Assureurs reports a decline in the frequency of several types of claims, but the average cost per claim is rising depending on the coverage. Drivers with no recent accidents may therefore still see their premiums go up. Choosing the right coverage for your vehicle means looking beyond the policy type shown and focusing on the clauses that actually affect compensation.
Vehicle lending and authorized drivers: clauses that make all the difference
Most policies include a regular or exclusive driver clause. Lending your car to someone who is not named on the policy does not suspend third-party liability coverage, but it can affect coverage for damage to the vehicle and the applicable excess.
Three points in the policy are worth reviewing before lending your car:
- The list of authorized drivers: some policies cover an exclusive driver (only the policyholder is covered without a surcharge), while others name a main driver and declare additional drivers. An undeclared driver may trigger a higher excess, sometimes double the usual amount, and may even result in damage coverage being excluded.
- The excess for a claim caused by an occasional driver: the surcharge or additional excess varies from one insurer to another, with no regulatory cap. Checking the exact amount can help you avoid an unpleasant surprise when the claim is settled.
- Use-related exclusions: a policy covering commuting may exclude a claim that occurs while the borrower is using the car for work. Lending the car does not change the declared use, and any discrepancy may justify a refusal to pay out.
Comparison sites rarely show these details. A low quote may conceal an exclusive-driver policy, where even a short loan of the car could leave you facing an excess twice as high as under a standard policy.
For more information on the differences between policy types and insurers, car insurance on Actu Auto Buzz provides further details on how these mechanisms work.

Tax on theft and fire coverage: a hidden extra cost in your premium
Since the decree of December 22, 2023, the tax on theft and fire coverage has risen from 6% to 9%. This increase applies directly to the portion of the premium corresponding to these coverages, not to the entire policy. For a comprehensive policy where theft and fire coverage make up a significant share of the premium, the impact is noticeable.
The problem is that most policyholders see this increase as a price hike imposed by the insurer. Separating the tax portion from the technical portion helps you determine whether switching insurers will actually lower your bill, or whether the tax will apply regardless of the policy.
Reviewing your premium statement
The annual premium statement normally breaks down the net premium, taxes by coverage, and administration fees. Comparing two quotes without checking these breakdowns is like comparing prices including tax without knowing which costs come from the insurer’s rates and which come from taxation. A policy advertised at a lower price may simply allocate costs differently across coverages, with a smaller share for theft and fire and therefore a lower tax—but also less coverage.
Electric vehicle coverage: battery, cable and running out of charge
Standard car insurance policies were not designed with the specific needs of electric vehicles in mind. Batteries, charging cables and incidents during charging are not covered consistently by all insurers.
Leased batteries illustrate the issue. If the battery remains the property of the manufacturer or a leasing company, the vehicle owner’s car insurance policy may exclude it on the grounds that it does not belong to them. If the battery is damaged in an accident, the policyholder may find themselves caught between two policies—the battery lessor’s and their own—with neither covering the full cost.
What to check before taking out a policy
- Does the policy explicitly cover the battery, whether purchased or leased, and at what value (new-for-old, residual or replacement value)?
- Is an incident during charging (power surge, fire at the charging point) covered under the fire guarantee, or is it subject to a specific exclusion?
- Is running out of charge (a flat battery) treated as a breakdown under the roadside assistance cover, or is it covered by a separate clause?
- Is the charging cable covered against theft or damage, and under which coverage?
A comparison based solely on the price of a comprehensive policy is not enough. The difference between two policies comes down to exclusions specific to electrical components, not the overall excess.

Insurance refusals and recourse to the Central Pricing Office
When a driver is considered too risky (a high penalty rating, a history of serious claims or an unusual vehicle), several insurers may refuse to provide cover. Third-party liability insurance is still compulsory, however. After receiving at least two documented refusals for this minimum coverage, drivers can apply to the Central Pricing Office.
This scheme has one limitation: it can require an insurer to provide third-party liability cover, but not additional coverage. There is no recourse that can force an insurer to offer theft, fire or comprehensive accidental damage cover. The driver is entitled to drive legally, but with protection limited to the legal minimum.
We find that this distinction is rarely explained to policyholders who turn to the scheme. They expect to get coverage comparable to their previous policy, when in fact they will only receive basic third-party liability cover, with no protection for the vehicle itself.
Choosing the right coverage is about more than deciding between third-party and comprehensive insurance. Clauses on lending your car, the tax on theft and fire coverage, electric vehicle requirements and recourse options all form part of a picture that price alone cannot capture. Reviewing your premium statement and policy terms remains the most worthwhile step before comparing quotes.



